Last Updated: November 15, 2026 Reading Time: 7 min

Two people asked on Reddit this weekend which FEHB plan to pick for 2027 with cancer treatment or major surgery ahead. For a household with one seriously ill person, a different number applies in some plans. In seven nationwide options, one sick family member stops paying eligible cost-sharing at the Self Only limit, which is lower than the family limit.

Plan (Self and Family, 2027) Worst case if one person is sick Worst case if the family reaches the family limit Difference
GEHA HDHP $11,606 $17,606 $6,000
Aetna Advantage $13,352 $21,852 $8,500
Aetna Direct $14,053 $22,053 $8,000
FEP Blue Focus $15,559 $26,559 $11,000
Aetna HealthFund HDHP $15,959 $23,459 $7,500
BCBS Basic $18,576 $27,076 $8,500
BCBS Standard $19,919 $26,919 $7,000

Each figure is a year of 2027 premiums (the non-Postal employee share, 26 paychecks) plus the plan's in-network out-of-pocket limit (the Self Only limit in the one-person column, the family limit in the other). Plan HSA deposits are not subtracted. The one-person column assumes that one member reaches the individual limit and other members incur no additional cost-sharing. Otherwise, add their cost-sharing, subject to the family limit.

The FEHB Out-of-Pocket Maximum Rule for One Person in a Family

The brochures we read each have a section called "Your catastrophic protection out-of-pocket maximum." It gives one limit for Self Only and a larger one for Self Plus One and Self and Family. The question is what happens when one person in a family enrollment has all the claims.

The 2027 brochures for these plans answer it directly.

  • BCBS Standard, BCBS Basic and FEP Blue Focus: "once any individual family member reaches the Self Only catastrophic protection out-of-pocket maximum during the calendar year, that member's claims will no longer be subject to associated cost-sharing amounts for the rest of the year. All other family members will be required to meet the balance of the catastrophic protection out-of-pocket maximum."
  • GEHA HDHP: "An individual under Self Plus One or Self and Family enrollment will never have to satisfy more than what is required for the out-of-pocket maximum under a Self Only enrollment."
  • Aetna HealthFund HDHP, Aetna Direct and Aetna Advantage: "Once an individual meets the Self Only out-of-pocket maximum under the Self Plus One or Self and Family enrollment, the Plan will begin to cover eligible medical expenses at 100%."

So in these plans, if only one person in a family plan has the big medical year, that person's eligible cost-sharing stops at the Self Only limit. The rest of the family keeps paying their own cost-sharing until the family limit is met.

Aetna's brochure says its in-network and out-of-network limits "do not cross apply."

What a One-Person Bad Year Costs in 2027

The table at the top is for Self and Family. Here is the same calculation for Self Plus One: a year of Self Plus One premiums plus the Self Only limit. It assumes that one member reaches the individual limit and the other incurs no additional cost-sharing.

Plan (Self Plus One, 2027) Worst case if one person is sick
GEHA HDHP $10,562
Aetna Advantage $12,529
Aetna Direct $13,264
FEP Blue Focus $15,145
Aetna HealthFund HDHP $17,348
BCBS Basic $17,612
BCBS Standard $18,697

How we computed it: FedTools added each plan's 2027 employee premium (26 paychecks) to its in-network out-of-pocket maximum. For the one-person case we used the Self Only limit with the family premium. Premiums are the 2027 employee share for non-Postal federal employees, paid every two weeks. Retirees pay monthly, and Postal employees are in PSHB. We rounded once, at the end. For GEHA HDHP, for example, $215.63 times 26 is $5,606.38, plus the $6,000 Self Only limit, which gives $11,606.

We checked the Self Only limit for all seven options against their 2027 brochures.

Two notes on reading the tables:

  • GEHA HDHP's HSA deposit is separate. GEHA HDHP deposits up to $1,000 (Self Only) or $2,000 (family) in your HSA in 2027 if you are HSA-eligible all year. We did not subtract it. If you are not HSA-eligible, the brochure describes an HRA credit instead.
  • Aetna Direct's fund does not lower the limit. Aetna Direct spends its $900 fund first, then you still owe up to the full $8,000 limit (Self Only).

These tables rank a worst-case year. These estimates assume the ordinary FEHB benefits without Medicare or other insurance coordination. If you or a covered family member has Medicare, this ranking may not fit your household. They don't tell you which plan covers your doctors, your hospital or your drugs, so we are not calling any plan the best one for cancer care or surgery.

What the Limit Does Not Cover

Hitting the limit does not mean you stop paying for everything.

Only eligible deductible, coinsurance and copayment expenses count toward the limit. Some covered services are excluded; Aetna Direct and Aetna Advantage exclude specified medical infertility expenses. Your premium never counts toward it. That is why every figure on this page adds a year of premiums on top.

Balance bills, non-covered services and specified penalties remain payable after the limit. Brand-over-generic differentials are excluded in BCBS, GEHA HDHP, Aetna HealthFund HDHP and Aetna Direct; confirm Aetna Advantage's treatment with the plan.

Drug rules differ by plan, and they matter in a year of cancer treatment:

  • In GEHA HDHP, drug coinsurance counts toward the limit.
  • In Aetna Advantage, a drug-maker coupon used for a specialty drug does not count toward your limit. Ask any plan how it treats copay coupons.

The limit also runs on a calendar year, so treatment that starts in the fall and continues into spring falls under two years' limits.

How to Use This Before Open Season Ends

  1. Decide which case you are in. Use the one-person column when one member reaches the individual limit and other members incur no additional cost-sharing. Otherwise, add their cost-sharing, subject to the family limit.
  2. Check the network first. A low worst-case figure does not help if your oncologist, surgeon or hospital is out of network. FEP Blue Focus and BCBS Basic pay only for in-network care, with exceptions in their brochures.
  3. Read Section 4 of the 2027 brochure for any plan not on this page. Look for the sentence about an individual under a family enrollment. We did not read it for GEHA Standard, GEHA High, GEHA Elevate, MHBP or the association plans, so we can't tell you they work the same way.
  4. Ask the plan about your drugs. Find out the tier and whether a copay coupon counts toward the limit.

For the full ranking of nationwide plans by premium plus out-of-pocket limit, see FEHB 2027: Compare Plans by Total Cost, Not Premium. If you are leaving MHBP, see Compass Rose vs SAMBA vs Blue Focus.

Open Season ends Monday, December 14, 2026, unless OPM changes the dates. For FEHB employees, a change takes effect in the first pay period that begins in January 2027.

Compare 2027 Plans Side by Side

Use our free FEHB Plan Comparison to put two or three plans next to each other. Pick the plans and your enrollment type, and it shows 2027 premiums with deductibles and out-of-pocket limits. Compare plans now

Frequently Asked Questions

If one person in my FEHB family plan has cancer, do we owe the whole family limit?

Not in the seven options we read. In BCBS Standard, BCBS Basic, FEP Blue Focus, GEHA HDHP, Aetna HealthFund HDHP, Aetna Direct and Aetna Advantage, that person stops paying eligible cost-sharing at the Self Only limit. Other family members keep counting toward the family limit.

Which FEHB plan has the lowest worst-case cost for a family with one sick person in 2027?

Among the seven options whose brochures we read, GEHA HDHP is lowest for Self and Family at $11,606: a year of non-Postal employee premiums plus the $6,000 Self Only limit. It assumes that one member reaches the individual limit and other members incur no additional cost-sharing. That figure does not tell you whether your doctors and drugs are covered, so check the network and the drug list before you choose.

Does my FEHB premium count toward the out-of-pocket maximum?

No. Only eligible deductible, coinsurance and copayment expenses count toward the limit. Some covered services are excluded; Aetna Direct and Aetna Advantage exclude specified medical infertility expenses. Your premium never counts toward it.

What do I still pay after I reach the FEHB out-of-pocket maximum?

Balance bills, non-covered services and specified penalties remain payable after the limit. Brand-over-generic differentials are excluded in BCBS, GEHA HDHP, Aetna HealthFund HDHP and Aetna Direct; confirm Aetna Advantage's treatment with the plan. You also keep paying your premium.

Does the one-person rule apply to every FEHB plan?

We can only confirm it for the seven options whose 2027 brochures we read. For any other plan, read Section 4 of its 2027 brochure and look for the sentence about an individual under a Self Plus One or Self and Family enrollment.

Sources