Last Updated: November 22, 2026 Reading Time: 9 min

FEHB HDHP vs CDHP comes down to one question: who owns the money in the account? A high deductible health plan (HDHP) comes with a health savings account that belongs to you. A consumer-driven health plan (CDHP) comes with a fund that belongs to the plan. Both put dollars in an account, so they look alike in the plan tables. Here is how they differ for 2027, with the dollar figures for four named plans.

HDHP and CDHP side by side for 2027

Question HDHP with an HSA HDHP with an HRA (if you can't have an HSA) CDHP fund (Personal Care Account or Medical Fund)
Who owns the money? You The plan. It is a fund of credits, not a bank account The plan. OPM classes it as an HRA
Can you add your own money? Yes, up to the IRS limit: $4,500 self-only or $9,000 family in 2027, counting the plan's deposit No No
Does it roll over? Yes, every year, with no cap Yes, while you stay in the plan Yes, while you stay in the plan; APWU's verified cap is shown below
Does it leave with you? Yes. It stays yours when you change plans, leave federal service or retire No. You lose it if you switch health plans or leave federal service other than by retiring. If you retire and keep the same plan, it continues No. OPM says an HRA is not portable
Tax Goes in untaxed, grows tax-free, comes out tax-free for qualified medical expenses Tax-free when it pays qualified medical bills. It can never be paid to you as cash Same as an HRA
2027 examples GEHA HDHP, Aetna HealthFund HDHP The same HDHPs, for members on Medicare or TRICARE Aetna Direct, APWU Consumer Driven Option

What Makes a Plan an HDHP, and What Makes It a CDHP

An HDHP is a tax-law category. To count as an HDHP in 2027, a plan needs a deductible of at least $1,750 (self-only) or $3,500 (family) and an out-of-pocket cap no higher than $8,700 or $17,400. Meeting that test is what lets you pair the plan with an HSA.

A CDHP has no tax-law test. It is a label for a plan that pairs coverage with a plan-funded account. OPM classes that account, whether it is called a Personal Care Account or a Medical Fund, as a health reimbursement arrangement (HRA): you can't deposit into it and it is not portable.

A consumer-driven plan is not an HSA plan. Its fund is a general-purpose HRA, so months in one generally add no new HSA contribution room. You can still spend an HSA you already have.

The HSA: Your Money, for Good

An HSA is yours. It stays with you when you change plans, leave federal service or retire. Unused money carries over every year with no cap. If your spouse is the named beneficiary, the HSA becomes your spouse's HSA at your death.

The tax treatment has three parts. HSA money goes in untaxed, grows tax-free and comes out tax-free for qualified medical expenses, with or without current HDHP coverage.

Money taken out for non-medical use is taxed as income plus a 20% additional tax. The 20% no longer applies once you are 65, disabled, or after death. The income tax still applies.

FEHB HDHPs put part of your premium into your HSA each month. This is the premium pass-through. It isn't taxable income and you can't deduct it. It does count toward the $4,500 or $9,000 limit, so subtract it to find your own room. The limit accrues one-twelfth for each month you are eligible.

One timing rule applies in December. If you are HSA-eligible on December 1, you may contribute the full year's limit, but you must stay eligible through December 31 of the next year. Fail that for a reason other than death or disability and the extra contributions become income.

Who Cannot Contribute to an HSA

HSA eligibility is checked on the first day of each month. You need HDHP coverage and generally cannot also have a non-HDHP health plan covering the same benefits, apart from coverage the law disregards, such as dental and vision.

Situation Can you contribute to an HSA?
Entitled to Medicare No. Your limit is zero for that month and every later month. You can still spend the HSA you already have
TRICARE or TRICARE For Life No, per OPM. An FEHB HDHP gives you an HRA instead
A regular health care FSA, yours or your spouse's Generally no. FSAFEDS's Limited Expense FSA for dental and vision does not block it
Someone else can claim you as a dependent on their tax return No
VA care for a service-connected disability Yes. Veterans who get VA hospital care or medical services for a service-connected disability stay HSA-eligible
Other VA or Indian Health Service care in the previous three months No, per OPM guidance

If you can't have an HSA, the HDHP gives you an HRA instead. It is a plan-run fund of credits, not a bank account, and you can't add your own money. HRA credits roll over while you stay in the plan. You lose them if you switch health plans or leave federal service other than by retiring. If you retire and keep the same plan, the HRA continues.

The Medicare lookback for people who work past 65

If you delay Medicare and your enrollment is later backdated, HSA contributions made for the backdated months count as excess contributions. Premium-free Part A is backdated when you apply after 65: up to 6 months, but never earlier than the first month you were eligible (42 C.F.R. § 406.6(d)(4)).

Part A also comes with Social Security once you are 65. If you are drawing Social Security at 65, or start it later, no separate Part A application is needed.

So stop HSA contributions, including the plan's deposits where you can, at least 6 months before you apply for Medicare or Social Security after 65. Contributions above your limit are generally hit with a 6% excise tax for each year they stay in the account. Our post on Social Security and Medicare timing for FERS retirees covers the timing.

The CDHP Fund: The Plan's Money

A CDHP fund is tax-free when it pays qualified medical bills. But only the plan can put money in, and it can never be paid out to you as cash.

The fund is loaded by the plan and pays your first medical bills of the year. Unused money rolls over only while you stay enrolled, subject to the plan's rollover rules. We did not find text in either plan's brochure on what happens to the fund at retirement, so ask the plan before you count on it.

2027 Dollars for Four Named Plans

Plan (type) 2027 account funding Rollover and exit Other 2027 figures
GEHA HDHP (HDHP) $83.33 a month for Self Only, about $1,000 a year. $166.66 a month for two or more, about $2,000. Paid as an HSA, or as an HRA for members who can't have an HSA HSA: yours. HRA: not portable Deductible $1,800 per person
Aetna HealthFund HDHP (HDHP) $66.67 a month for Self Only, $800 a year. $133.34 a month for two or more, $1,600 HSA: yours In-network deductible $2,000 or $4,000. In-network out-of-pocket maximum $7,500 for Self Only; confirm the family maximum in the 2027 brochure. You must live or work in its service area
Aetna Direct (CDHP) Medical Fund of $900 for Self Only, $1,800 for two or more, per year Unused funds may roll over while you remain in the option; confirm the rollover cap in the 2027 brochure. You forfeit the balance if you leave the plan In-network out-of-pocket maximum $8,000 or $16,000. The fund does not shrink the deductible or that maximum
APWU Consumer Driven Option (CDHP) Personal Care Account of $1,200 for Self Only, $2,400 for two or more, loaded by the plan in January Rolls over as long as you remain in the plan, up to a balance of $5,000 or $10,000 In-network out-of-pocket maximum $6,500 or $13,000. Employee share $102.63, $223.06 or $243.34 per pay period

Source: each plan's 2027 FEHB brochure. "Two or more" means Self Plus One or Self and Family. GEHA pays its deposit for each month you are eligible.

Three notes on what is not in this table. For 2027 Aetna's options in this brochure are the HealthFund HDHP and Aetna Direct, and Aetna Direct is the consumer-driven one. MHBP's Consumer Option ends after 2026, which we cover in MHBP Consumer Option ending. And for Postal employees and retirees, NALC's CDHP in PSHB carries a Personal Care Account that earns no interest and is not portable if you leave federal service or switch plans. We could not confirm a NALC consumer-driven option in FEHB for 2027; postal readers have one in PSHB.

Which Account Fits Your Situation

We are not naming a best plan. These four cases sort the question.

  • You can have an HSA and won't spend the whole deposit this year. The HDHP dollar is worth more, because it is yours for good and you can add your own money on top.
  • You are entitled to Medicare, or you have TRICARE. You cannot contribute to an HSA. The comparison is one plan fund against another: the HDHP's HRA or a CDHP fund. Compare the fund amounts, the premiums and the out-of-pocket maximums.
  • You plan to change plans or leave federal service soon. An HSA goes with you. HRA credits and a CDHP fund do not, except that an HDHP's HRA continues if you retire and keep the same plan.
  • You are near 65 and still working. Read the Medicare lookback section above before you choose an HDHP for the HSA.

If you are moving an existing HSA into a new HDHP, see how to move your HSA when you switch FEHB HDHPs. Open Season ends Monday, December 14, 2026, unless OPM changes the dates.

Compare Your FEHB Plan Options

Use our free FEHB Plan Comparison tool to put two plans side by side on premiums and cost sharing for 2027. Compare annual premiums separately from account funding. An HSA deposit becomes your money; an HRA or CDHP credit offsets only eligible expenses under the plan's rules, so count only the credit you expect to use or retain. For 2027 limits on HSAs, FSAs and the TSP together, see 2027 limits in one table.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between an HDHP and a CDHP in FEHB?

An HDHP is a plan that meets the tax-law deductible test and can be paired with a health savings account that you own and keep. A CDHP pairs coverage with a plan-funded account that OPM classes as an HRA: you can't deposit into it and it is not portable. HDHP members who can't have an HSA, for example because they are entitled to Medicare, get an HRA instead.

What is the HSA contribution limit for 2027?

For 2027 the HSA limit is $4,500 for self-only coverage and $9,000 for family coverage, and the plan's deposit counts toward it. Self Plus One counts as family coverage. If you are 55 or older by year-end, the HSA catch-up adds $1,000 to the limit. The limit accrues one-twelfth for each month you are eligible.

Can I contribute to an HSA if I have Medicare, TRICARE or VA care?

Once you are entitled to Medicare, your HSA contribution limit is zero for that month and every later month. OPM says TRICARE and TRICARE For Life also bar an HSA. Veterans who get VA care for a service-connected disability stay HSA-eligible, while OPM says other VA or Indian Health Service care in the previous three months makes you ineligible. You can still spend an HSA you already have.

Do I keep my HSA or my CDHP fund if I leave my plan?

An HSA is yours and stays with you when you change plans, leave federal service or retire. HRA credits in an HDHP are lost if you switch health plans or leave federal service other than by retiring. At Aetna Direct you forfeit the Medical Fund balance if you leave the plan, and APWU's fund rolls over as long as you remain in the plan.

Which FEHB plans are HDHPs or CDHPs in 2027?

Among the plans we read, GEHA HDHP and Aetna HealthFund HDHP are HDHPs for 2027, and Aetna Direct and the APWU Consumer Driven Option are consumer-driven plans. Aetna HealthFund HDHP requires you to live or work in its service area. MHBP's Consumer Option ends after 2026. Check OPM's 2027 plan list for other HDHPs in your area.

Should I stop HSA contributions before I apply for Medicare?

Yes, if you apply after 65. Premium-free Part A is backdated up to 6 months, but never earlier than the first month you were eligible, and HSA contributions made for backdated months count as excess contributions. Stop contributions, including the plan's deposits where you can, at least 6 months before you apply for Medicare or for Social Security after 65.

Sources